Meat Birds in the Easement — by Julia Frisbie

By Julia Frisbie

posted March 22, 2022

Our family is omnivorous, but we have serious concerns about both the ethics and the carbon footprint of conventionally raised meat. The more time we spend with our animals, the harder it is to imagine that they don’t have feelings, and the harder it is to eat meat raised on factory farms. I’ll never forget being passed by a flatbed semi on I-5, and glancing up to try and figure out why there was all this white fluff hitting my windshield… before realizing that the truck was stacked high with cages full of live chickens. After my initial bout of nausea, I wondered: why are we trucking chickens around on I-5, when they’re small enough to raise in any backyard?!

That was when I got motivated to raise my own meat chickens someday. I read books about the process. I took a weeklong class from Joel Salatin, a famous permaculturist who raises pastured poultry this way in Virginia. I learned that birds bred for meat production are basically defenseless against predators, and don’t fatten up if they get too much exercise. Rather than giving them a large area to roam, people who raise them on pasture do it in small pens which they move to fresh grass every day. This has the added benefit of stimulating extra carbon sequestration, just like any other rotational grazing plan but in miniature.

I even cleared it with the city planning department; they told me that as long as I didn’t erect any permanent structures, we could do whatever we wanted in the easement next to our house, including raising meat birds in a moveable pen. I asked, what about briefly exceeding the number of chickens allowed in the city code? Was that a problem? As long as it was temporary, and the adjacent neighbors didn’t complain, they weren’t too worried.

The only problem is, to raise chickens this way, you have to be at home every day for several consecutive months in order to move them daily so that they have access to fresh pasture. As two young professionals, we sometimes traveled for business, and we also visited family in Oregon several times a year. We couldn’t figure out how to make all that work with meat chickens, so we tabled the idea.

COVID-19 gave us the opening we needed. In March of 2020, as soon as it became clear that we’d be staying home for eleventy-bajillion days, we brought home 25 day-old “Freedom Ranger” chicks from the feed store. We set them up in a traditional brooder (okay, it was just a big cardboard box) with bedding, food, water, and a heat lamp. Usually we delegate the raising of chicks to a broody mama hen, but 25 is too many, even for a very good mama. This time, the raising would be up to us.

 

The very next day, we moved them and their food, water, and heat lamp into what we called our “outdoor brooder”: the bottom rung of an empty stacking compost barrel that was windproof and easy to clip the heat lamp to. Even tiny chicks can tolerate cold temperatures–  and quite enjoy the fresh air and sunshine– as long as they’ve got access to a 90-degree heat zone where they can warm up intermittently.

 

We moved this simple setup every day so that they had constant access to fresh grass. For two weeks, they commuted between their daytime outdoor brooder and their nighttime indoor brooder via bushel basket. Helping move the chicks was a favorite activity for our preschooler! They all looked the same, so he named them all Marshmallow.

 

Construction of a “chicken tractor” began. We built a three foot wide, ten foot long, two foot tall box with a slide-open door on each end. We attached steel roofing panels to one of the long sides and two thirds of the top so they’d get a nice balance of sunshine and shelter. Where we didn’t put roofing panels, we put hardware cloth. We left the bottom open. It was heavy enough not to blow away or get knocked over by a curious predator, but light enough that two adults could easily lift it a few inches off the ground and move it to a new spot.

On April 7, we put the chicken tractor in the easement, loaded all the chicks into a wheelbarrow (because they didn’t fit in the bushel basket anymore) and moved them into their new home. They immediately started running around, scratching, and sunbathing. They would still need a heat lamp on at night for a few weeks until they were fully feathered, but after watching their happy behavior, we had no doubt: the chicken tractor was a good habitat. They quickly learned to move along the ground inside their new home each day when we carefully lifted it to fresh grass.

 

The chicks in the easement turned out to be a great conversation starter. Of course, everyone who lives on our block is used to our antics by now, and they didn’t bat an eye. But kids, exercisers, and dog-walkers from the larger neighborhood often stopped to look at the chicks and chat. People wanted to know how they got there, why they were in a different place every day, and what we were going to do with that many chickens. Responses upon learning that we planned to eat them ranged from polite to enthusiastic. Helpful neighbors alerted us when a teenage chicken tunneled out between two big tufts of grass, and when coyotes were seen and heard nearby. Several people volunteered to help move the tractor, visit on butcher day to learn how it was done, or even buy meat from us!

We didn’t grow enough chickens to sell, but I certainly understood the appeal. That spring, amid supply chain uncertainty and slaughterhouse shutdowns, the factory farming poultry company Tyson made headlines by “depopulating” millions of birds. That meant pumping toxic white foam into warehouses full of caged chickens until every bird asphyxiated. People were justifiably horrified… and scared about food security. Getting to watch meat being raised a different way in their own neighborhood was exciting.

 

Only one person reacted negatively. She knocked on our door to accuse us of animal cruelty because the cage was too small. I tried to explain that if meat birds have too much space, they don’t reach slaughter weight before they start to crow. She was unmoved. I told her they have access to fresh pasture daily when we moved the tractor. She was unimpressed. I asked her if she ate chicken, and she said yes, but she only ate organic chicken. She couldn’t tell me where her chicken came from, but she was 100% sure it was “running around outside.”

That’s not actually what the “organic” label means. Organic meat chickens in the USA have to be able to “access the outdoors,” but usually a covered screened-in porch is all they get. There is no requirement for square feet of space per bird, or access to pasture, sunlight, or soil. The USDA’s “free range” label also doesn’t guarantee a minimum amount of space… or even full-body access to the outdoors. On balance, I think a life with sunlight and fresh grass in a moveable tractor is preferable; one of the main reasons we embarked on this whole project was to avoid animal cruelty.

But, it was true, the chicken tractor was getting a bit crowded.

 

In honor of the organic chicken lady’s discomfort, I slaughtered the birds who were obviously boys so that there would be no crowing and everyone else would have more elbow room. This was not the solution she had in mind. She called the cops on us. We got an apologetic visit from a young officer who said, “They’re meat birds? And you’re slaughtering the rest soon? Umm, okay, I’m just going to write a note in the report that says they look healthy and they have everything they need.”

 

And that was that. A few weeks later, our calendar read “CHICKENMAGEDDON.” One by one I lured them out of the tractor with handfuls of treats, held them in my arms, thanked them for their lives and the nourishment they would provide to our family… and then chopped their heads off. I’m not going to lie: it was a hard day. We scalded, plucked, and eviscerated them (Harvey Ussery’s book The Small Scale Poultry Flock was a huge help). We packaged, labeled, and froze them. We gave one to each of the adjacent neighbors to thank them for not complaining to the city, and packed the rest into the chest freezer. 

We ate homegrown chicken, and drank homegrown chickenfoot broth, for more than a year. Meanwhile, the easement changed colors. Monoculture gave way to polyculture. The chickens’ grazing pressure created intermittent disturbance, their manure added fertility, and their spilled grain seeded oats, wheat, peas, mustards, and who knows what else out there. From a person’s perspective, it’s a bit untidy. For deer, bunnies, and birds, it looks like a complete meal. From a bug’s eye view it must be a jungle. Carbon was sequestered, just as surely as our freezer was filled. 

Would we do it again? We didn’t last year, and won’t this year. The cost-benefit analysis of our time and effort didn’t pencil out; we might as well buy expensive free range chicken at the farmer’s market. If our family had more free time and less disposable income, that calculation might work out differently. Or if we could do it cooperatively and on a slightly larger scale– for example, with one other family to share the labor, and 50 chickens instead of 25– that might tip the scales in favor of homegrown chicken. But I’m glad we did it once. It helped us imagine and experiment with a different relationship to meat. 

What if neighbors teamed up to raise chickens in easements? Or herd goats along the alleyways to keep the blackberries down? Or keep rabbit hutches along the shady edges of the forest? What if backyard hens became neighborhood hens, and each street had a dairy cow rotating through its front lawns? I know I’m every HOA’s worst nightmare, but… how much food could we raise right here? How would it change the way we eat, the way we landscape, and the way we interact with each other? 

The only way to know is to get creative, try it out, and see what happens. 

4 thoughts on “Meat Birds in the Easement — by Julia Frisbie

  1. Martha Hall

    I find it really interesting how people are experimenting with raising chickens and ducks and what is being learned. I am so glad that people are learning about other species and hopefully people are finding out that they too want to be alive
    and do what they enjoy, just like us. I’m glad people are realizing that the way these animals are usually raised is inhumane and cruel. Nothing is more educational than spending a lot of time with other species. It is even better when we do it on their terms and now how we want to do it. Every species has evolved in unique and fascinating ways and each has many things to contribute.

    Unfortunately domestication can change everything. So can the belief that these animals are here for us to use however we might want which is sometimes rooted in religion and sometimes in our belief that we are the superior
    species who has all of the rights and other species have few if any. These beliefs can be challenged by a more compassionate and less ego-centric view that sees the importance of each individual animal, whether human or
    non-human, and of all species.

    Like many other people I grew up in a meat-eating family with a father who hunted to provide much of our meat.
    Then I helped run a wildlife rescue center on our property for 18 years and learned a lot more about the other species.
    My husband and I had to stop eating animals and eggs because of what we learned. Yes, we have ultimate power to help or destroy other species. Some of us decide that ethics, compassion and opening up our minds to other ideas are all more important than power and tradition. When I read these posts about raising meat animals I see that people are evolving in their beliefs about other species and what is ethical and not ethical. This is a process and sometimes it takes a long time and a lot of soul searching.

    Today their are many healthy ways to eat without eating animals. Some are far healthier than eating meat. Yes, we had a few meat-related items we really missed, especially tuna fish and cheese. I should stress cheese was the hardest. Before taking this step I had to really find out for myself what happened to milk cows during the production of dairy products. I took the time to do this and I was shocked by what I found out.

    All of this was before climate change was really a main topic of discussion. Many more people are now choosing to not eat animal-related foods because of the amount of resources and space that are required to produce these compared to eating plant-based diets.

    I would say slugs are not one of my major gardening problems. Yes, we have years when we have a lot of slugs in our yard. Our native snakes eat slugs but our snake populations in Anacortes seem to vary a lot. The use of lawn mowers and poisons probably contribute to this. When I believe there are too many slugs, I simply add 15 minutes to my early
    morning schedule and go outside and collect them. It isn’t long before things are back to a more normal level. One of my major problems is neighborhood cats that are allowed to run loose. They are attracted to the birds in my yard, the birds that do a great job of eating grubs and adult insects in my yard. Nature does a great job of balancing things out when we allow nature to function in our yards. How, what and where we plant various species can help a lot. The way
    organic gardeners are experimenting with this is fascinating.

    We have a long way to go on all of these issues. That some people are thinking about our choices of what to eat and how to produce these foods is great. Maybe in the end we will come to some of the same conclusions. What many more people know now than a few years ago is that the current method of producing most of our foods comes with
    huge costs that still have not been well disclosed and analyzed. We are slowly reaching the time when this may actually happen. When this happens, we may be closer to finding ways to eat that are lighter on our planet and kinder to other species who just want to live a good life like we do.

    Reply
    1. Julia

      Hi Martha! I miss seeing you and Bob; it’s wonderful to hear from you!

      Yes, there are loads of excellent plant-based options, you’re absolutely right. I think raising our own meat actually helped us eat less of it, because all of a sudden chicken stopped being a cheap commodity and became this precious, limited resource that represented a lot of literal blood, sweat, and tears on our family’s part. We didn’t waste a morsel.

      I love your comment about the snakes. I’d actually been asking for ducks for about 5 years by the time Drew finally gave in, and the reason he relented was that I issued an ultimatum: “Aaack! I collect and kill a pint of slugs every morning, and the ones that are left still ate $350 worth of speciality narcissus this month! NARCISSUS!!! Nobody’s supposed to eat those, not even the deer! That’s it, we need biological control. I’m getting ducks or snakes. Your choice.” Him: “…neither?” Me: “DUCKS OR SNAKES! YOUR CHOICE!!!” Him: “Ducks, I guess.”

      Reply
  2. Marvin Elsberry

    Good for you guys Julia, sounds like my upbringing in a small village in Nebraska. We had free range ducks, chickens, pigs, and cows. One persons opinion vs another’s regarding free range is up to Mr. Green Jeans (any farmer).
    Enjoyed your perspective and your time to write this summary.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.